Notes on Athey and Nekipelov, A Structural Model of Sponsored Search Advertising Auctions

As with all my handwritten notes, this has the usual disclaimer: these posts are just so I can use nice indexed search to find my notes, which are sufficient for me to recall talks and papers but probably not much use to anyone else. Slides here. Paper here.

Sponsored links that appear beside internet search results on the major search engines are sold using real-time auctions, where advertisers place standing bids that are entered in an auction each time a user types in a search query. The ranking of advertisements and the prices paid depend on advertiser bids as well as “quality scores” that are assigned for each advertisement and user query. Existing models assume that bids are customized for a single user query and the associated quality scores; however, in practice that is impossible, as queries arrive more quickly than advertisers can change their bids, and advertisers cannot perfectly predict changes in quality scores. This paper develops a new model where bids apply to many user queries, while the quality scores and the set of competing advertisements may vary from query to query. In contrast to existing models that ignore uncertainty, which produce multiplicity of equilibria, we provide sufficient conditions for existence and uniqueness of equilibria, and we provide evidence that these conditions are satisfied empirically. We show that the necessary conditions for equilibrium bids can be expressed as an ordinary differential equation.

We then propose a structural econometric model. With sufficient uncertainty in the environment, the valuations are point-identified, otherwise, we propose a bounds approach. We develop an estimator for bidder valuations, which we show is consistent and asymptotically normal. We provide Monte Carlo analysis to assess the small sample properties of the estimator. We also develop a tractable computational approach to calculate counterfactual equilibria of the auctions.
Finally, we apply the model to historical data for several keywords. We show that our model yields lower implied valuations and bidder profits than approaches that ignore uncertainty. We find that bidders have substantial strategic incentives to reduce their expressed demand in order to reduce the unit prices they pay in the auctions, and in addition, these incentives are asymmetric across bidders, leading to inefficient allocation. We show that for the keywords we study, the auction mechanism used in practice is not only strictly less efficient than a Vickrey auction, but it also raises less revenue.

Notes on Athey and Nekipelov, A Structural Model of Sponsored Search Advertising Auctions

One thought on “Notes on Athey and Nekipelov, A Structural Model of Sponsored Search Advertising Auctions

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s